What is Weeknight Win?

Weeknight Win is a free grocery delivery price comparison tool. Build a basket of staples and we instantly show all-in totals — subtotal, fees, and suggested tip — at Walmart+, Whole Foods, Instacart-Aldi, and Amazon Fresh side by side. The site also includes a free meal planner with 600+ recipes if you want to plan a week of dinners around what you're buying.

Is Weeknight Win really free?

Yes. The price comparison tool requires no signup and has no email gate. The meal planner is also free; sign-up is only required if you want to save recipes and persist your grocery list. The site is supported by an Instacart affiliate partnership when you choose to checkout there for delivery.

How accurate are the prices in the comparison tool?

Each price is anchored to a real source: BLS monthly retail food price surveys, Aldi's weekly digital ad, Whole Foods' Amazon-hosted product pages, and manually-audited Walmart prices. Each item shows a verified · X days ago badge so you know how fresh the data is. Fees and tip estimates use each service's posted fee schedule, region-adjusted via your zip.

Which grocery delivery service is cheapest?

It depends on your basket. For a typical 12-item weekly basket in NYC: Instacart-Aldi $45.30, Walmart+ $51.29, Amazon Fresh $58.87, Whole Foods $71.54. Instacart-Aldi is usually the cheapest for standard staples; Walmart+ wins on bigger baskets ($75+) where its free-over-$35 delivery threshold kicks in. Use the tool to check your specific basket.

Do I need an account to use the price comparison tool?

No. The comparison tool works without signup. You only need an account if you want to save recipes, plan a week of meals, or persist a shopping cart across sessions.

How is this different from a meal kit like HelloFresh?

Meal kits charge $80-$200 a week to ship pre-portioned ingredients. We don't ship anything — we tell you which delivery service is cheapest for what you actually want to buy, then send your list to your service of choice. Average savings: ~$26 per weekly basket just by picking the right service.

Side-by-side, 2026Updated May 2026

Aldi vs Amazon Fresh

Aldi via Instacart ($45.30) vs Amazon Fresh ($58.87) on the same 12-item basket — 23% cheaper at Aldi. Fee stacks, Prime math, and when each one wins.

Same 12-item basket

live, NYC

Aldi is $13.57 cheaper than Amazon Fresh (23% less).

AldiCheapest$45.30
Service fee 5% · Delivery $5.99 · Tip 10% suggested
Amazon Fresh$58.87
Service fee $0 · Delivery $9.95 · Tip none

Compare your own basket

The headline

On our modeled 12-item NYC basket, Aldi via Instacart comes to $45.30 all-in versus $58.87 at Amazon Fresh — a $13.57 gap, about 23% cheaper at Aldi. The interesting part is how differently the two get there. Aldi's shelf prices are much lower, but Instacart stacks three fees on every order: a 5% service fee, $5.99 delivery, and a 10% suggested tip. Amazon Fresh's shelf prices run higher, but checkout is flat — no service fee, no tip prompt, $9.95 delivery that drops to free over $100 — with Prime's $139/yr as the price of admission.

When Aldi wins

Aldi wins whenever the lowest total is the goal. Its private-label, small-SKU model keeps shelf prices low enough that even after Instacart's full fee stack, the modeled basket still lands 23% below Amazon Fresh. Aldi also asks for no annual commitment — you pay per order, which suits households that only order delivery a couple of times a month and can't justify $139/yr for Prime. The caveat: those fees repeat on every order. Splitting one weekly shop into three small orders means paying $5.99 delivery and a tip three times, which erodes the shelf-price advantage fast. Consolidate into one weekly basket.

When Amazon Fresh wins

Amazon Fresh wins if Prime is already on your card. With the membership treated as sunk cost, the per-order experience is the cleanest in grocery delivery: no service fee, no tip prompt, and a flat $9.95 delivery that disappears entirely on $100+ orders — the cart total is essentially the card total. Fresh also carries the name brands and household goods Aldi's ~1,500-SKU lineup skips, and since Amazon moved Whole Foods fulfillment in-house (Instacart no longer delivers Whole Foods), one Prime login covers both conventional and premium groceries. If you batch big $100+ orders, your only overhead is the membership.

The fee math

Aldi via Instacart: 5% service fee plus a 10% suggested tip on the subtotal, plus $5.99 delivery on $35+ orders — on every single order. Amazon Fresh: Prime at $139/yr, then $9.95 flat delivery below $100, free above, no tip. The crossover is really about what you already pay for. If Prime is a sunk cost, Fresh's flat fees narrow the gap on big consolidated orders. If you'd be buying Prime just for groceries, that $139 is a real grocery cost, and the modeled basket says Aldi keeps the win. Lowest total: Aldi. Cleanest checkout: Fresh.

Frequently asked

Is Aldi cheaper than Amazon Fresh?

Yes. On our modeled 12-item NYC basket, Aldi via Instacart totals $45.30 all-in versus $58.87 at Amazon Fresh — about 23% cheaper, even after Instacart's 5% service fee, $5.99 delivery, and 10% suggested tip are counted.

Does Aldi deliver without Instacart?

No. Aldi grocery delivery in the US runs through Instacart — orders placed on aldi.us or the Aldi app are shopped and delivered by Instacart, and Instacart's fee structure applies either way.

Do you need Amazon Prime for Amazon Fresh?

Yes. Amazon Fresh requires a Prime membership ($139/yr). Delivery is then a flat $9.95 per order, free on orders of $100 or more, with no tip prompt at checkout.

Why does Amazon Fresh feel cheaper at checkout?

Because the fee list is shorter. Fresh shows one flat delivery line and no tip, while Instacart adds a service fee, delivery fee, and suggested tip as separate lines. On our modeled basket, Aldi's lower shelf prices still beat Fresh's cleaner checkout by $13.57.

Can I order Whole Foods through Instacart instead of Amazon?

No. Amazon moved Whole Foods delivery in-house in 2022-2023, and Instacart no longer delivers Whole Foods. Whole Foods orders now run through the same Amazon/Prime pipeline as Amazon Fresh.

Free tool · No signup

Try it with your own basket.

Pick from 100 staples. We'll show the all-in total at all 5 services with live prices, fees, and tip — region-aware, refreshed daily.

Open the comparison tool