What is Weeknight Win?

Weeknight Win is a free grocery delivery price comparison tool. Build a basket of staples and we instantly show all-in totals — subtotal, fees, and suggested tip — at Walmart+, Whole Foods, Instacart-Aldi, and Amazon Fresh side by side. The site also includes a free meal planner with 600+ recipes if you want to plan a week of dinners around what you're buying.

Is Weeknight Win really free?

Yes. The price comparison tool requires no signup and has no email gate. The meal planner is also free; sign-up is only required if you want to save recipes and persist your grocery list. The site is supported by an Instacart affiliate partnership when you choose to checkout there for delivery.

How accurate are the prices in the comparison tool?

Each price is anchored to a real source: BLS monthly retail food price surveys, Aldi's weekly digital ad, Whole Foods' Amazon-hosted product pages, and manually-audited Walmart prices. Each item shows a verified · X days ago badge so you know how fresh the data is. Fees and tip estimates use each service's posted fee schedule, region-adjusted via your zip.

Which grocery delivery service is cheapest?

It depends on your basket. For a typical 12-item weekly basket in NYC: Instacart-Aldi $45.30, Walmart+ $51.29, Amazon Fresh $58.87, Whole Foods $71.54. Instacart-Aldi is usually the cheapest for standard staples; Walmart+ wins on bigger baskets ($75+) where its free-over-$35 delivery threshold kicks in. Use the tool to check your specific basket.

Do I need an account to use the price comparison tool?

No. The comparison tool works without signup. You only need an account if you want to save recipes, plan a week of meals, or persist a shopping cart across sessions.

How is this different from a meal kit like HelloFresh?

Meal kits charge $80-$200 a week to ship pre-portioned ingredients. We don't ship anything — we tell you which delivery service is cheapest for what you actually want to buy, then send your list to your service of choice. Average savings: ~$26 per weekly basket just by picking the right service.

City guideUpdated May 2026

Cheapest grocery delivery in New York City.

We priced the same 12-item basket at all four major grocery delivery services using New York City-area zip 10025. Here's how they stack up.

New York City basket — 12 items

Northeast Urban

Cheapest is $26.24 less than the most expensive (37% gap) for the identical basket.

Instacart-AldiCheapest$45.30
Walmart+$51.29
Amazon Fresh$58.87
Whole Foods$71.54

Try your own basket See live New York City prices for 100 items

New York City grocery delivery: head-to-head

Is Instacart cheaper than Walmart in New York City?

For our standard 12-item basket in New York City, Instacart-Aldi is cheaper at $45.30 versus $51.29 at the other — a gap of 12% for the identical basket. Whole Foods is meaningfully pricier than both at $71.54. See the full Instacart vs Walmart breakdown.

Is Aldi cheaper than Walmart in New York City?

Aldi (delivered via Instacart) hits $45.30 on the same 12-item basket in New York City; Walmart+ comes in at $51.29. Aldi wins by $5.99 here. The gap usually flips in Walmart's favor on larger baskets ($75+) because Walmart+ members get free delivery, while Instacart fees stack with every order. Aldi vs Walmart full comparison.

Is Amazon Fresh cheaper than Walmart in New York City?

New York City pricing puts Amazon Fresh at $58.87 and Walmart+ at $51.29. Walmart+ is cheaper for this basket. Note Amazon Fresh requires a Prime membership ($139/yr) to access at all, so unless you're already paying for Prime, the effective cost is higher than the basket total suggests. Amazon Fresh vs Walmart full comparison.

What is the cheapest grocery delivery in New York City?

Instacart-Aldi is the cheapest grocery delivery in New York City for this basket, at $45.30 all-in (subtotal + service fees + delivery + suggested tip). The ranking from cheapest to priciest: Instacart-Aldi ($45.30) → Walmart+ ($51.29) → Amazon Fresh ($58.87) → Whole Foods ($71.54). Your zip's exact ranking can shift with basket size and Prime membership — run your own basket through the calculator for the precise number.

Delivery coverage in New York City

NYC has the densest grocery delivery coverage in the country. Instacart's Marketplace serves Aldi (Queens, Brooklyn), Wegmans (Astoria), Sprouts, Stop & Shop, and dozens of regional grocers across all five boroughs. Walmart+ delivery covers most outer-borough zips but skips Manhattan (no Walmart stores). Amazon Fresh — which now handles Whole Foods delivery too, after Amazon ended the Instacart × Whole Foods partnership in 2022-2023 — has same-day Prime delivery across nearly all of Manhattan and Brooklyn.

The New York City grocery scene

Manhattan apartments rarely have room for bulk shopping, which is why same-day delivery here is a category leader in adoption rate. The five boroughs price differently from each other — Aldi via Instacart serves Queens and Brooklyn but not most of Manhattan; Whole Foods orders now go through Amazon Fresh's same-day Prime delivery (broadest Manhattan footprint); Wegmans Astoria opened in 2020 and changed Northeast Queens pricing overnight. Building access is the silent variable: many NYC apartments require leaving deliveries with doormen or in lobbies, which drives more frequent, smaller orders than the national average.

What we recommend for New York City

Instacart-Aldi is the cheapest option for most NYC zips. Walmart+ is competitive in Queens and Staten Island when its zips qualify.

For Manhattan zips, default to Amazon Fresh + Whole Foods for produce quality and Instacart-Aldi for pantry staples (delivered via Queens/Brooklyn) — splitting the basket saves about 18% versus a single all-Whole Foods order.

Northeast Urban pricing tends to run about 5% above the US average. That regional adjustment is built into the totals above.

Frequently asked in New York City

What is the cheapest grocery delivery in NYC?

For a 12-item weekly basket in Manhattan, Instacart-Aldi at $45.30 is consistently cheapest. Walmart+ comes in around $51.29, Amazon Fresh $58.87, and Whole Foods $71.54 (delivered through Amazon Fresh). The gap widens for larger baskets because Walmart+ delivery is free above $35 for members.

Does Aldi deliver in Manhattan?

Aldi has limited Manhattan presence — most Aldi delivery via Instacart in NYC originates from Queens and Brooklyn stores. Delivery times to Manhattan are often 2+ hours because the nearest Aldi can be a borough away. For same-borough Manhattan delivery, Amazon Fresh (which now carries Whole Foods inventory), Trader Joe's, and Wegmans are faster.

Does Instacart still deliver Whole Foods?

No. Amazon ended the Instacart × Whole Foods partnership in 2022-2023 after acquiring Whole Foods Market. Whole Foods orders now go exclusively through Amazon Fresh, requiring an Amazon Prime membership ($139/yr). Free delivery on $100+, $9.95 below. The pricing in our comparison reflects this Amazon Fresh fulfillment path.

Is Walmart+ membership worth it in NYC?

For shoppers who order grocery delivery 25+ times per year and live within Walmart's outer-borough delivery zones (Queens, Staten Island, parts of Brooklyn), yes — the $98/yr membership pays back via free delivery on orders above $35. Manhattan residents typically don't see Walmart+ coverage and should skip it.

Free tool · No signup

Build your New York City basket.

Pick from 100 staples. See all 5 services side-by-side with live prices, fees, and tip — already pre-set to Northeast Urban pricing.

Open the comparison tool

Other cities

See all 20 cities →