Peanut butter, creamy price in Los Angeles.
Live shelf prices for peanut butter, creamy (16 oz) across all four major grocery delivery services in Los Angeles, CA.
Peanut butter, creamy · 16 oz
West Urban- Instacart — AldiCheapest$2.95
- Walmart+$3.21
- Amazon Fresh (Prime)$3.69
- Instacart — Whole Foods$6.42
Shelf price only — total delivered cost depends on basket size, fees, and tip.
Compare full basketHow we got these numbers
- Instacart — Aldi:Category multiplier against Walmart base, adjusted for West Urban ($2.95)
- Walmart+:Regional baseline ($3.21)
- Amazon Fresh (Prime):Category multiplier against Walmart base, adjusted for West Urban ($3.69)
- Instacart — Whole Foods:Category multiplier against Walmart base, adjusted for West Urban ($6.42)
Live observations come from public weekly ads (Aldi, Whole Foods) and BLS Average Retail Food Prices, refreshed daily. Estimates use a per-category multiplier calibrated to NPR, Consumer Reports, and Tasting Table grocery comparison studies.
Why this category prices the way it does
Pantry staples (rice, pasta, flour) carry the smallest absolute price differences but the largest percentage gap — Aldi's private label routinely runs 40-60% under branded equivalents.
Los Angeles grocery context
LA's 500-square-mile sprawl means delivery zones vary dramatically — a Glendale zip may have 3-hour same-day delivery while a Malibu address can't get next-day from anyone. Aldi's LA footprint expanded aggressively in 2024, opening stores in Inglewood, Long Beach, and the Valley. Bristol Farms and Gelson's on Instacart serve the premium organic market that Whole Foods historically owned. Traffic affects delivery windows more here than anywhere else — Wednesday and Sunday afternoons get the most reliable windows.
If you're in the LA Basin or Valley, default to Instacart-Aldi for staples and Sprouts (also via Instacart) for produce — combined basket runs 25% cheaper than Whole Foods for similar quality. West LA residents should check Walmart+ coverage; the Inglewood and Crenshaw stores anchor most West LA delivery.
Add peanut butter, creamy to a full basket and compare totals.
Service fees, delivery, and tip all depend on basket size — the cheapest per-item service isn't always the cheapest overall.
Open the comparison tool